Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Sites | Writers | Advertise | My Orble | Login

Deep Pencil - the musings of Morgan Bell

 
If a tree falls in the woods and nobody is there to hear it did it really make a sound? If i post a blog and nobody reads it was there really any point? You have entered the random thinking space of Morgan Bell . . . These are my musings . . . things about my life written off the top of my head . . . written in an informal disjointed style almost completely devoid of punctuation, this is where i flesh out writing ideas, discuss my life, and generally be self indulgent . . . it is also the bargain bin for articles which do not fit in with the film or arts themes of my other blogs . . . so have a wander around my mind, have a laugh, have a think, be nice, and humour me!

Pillars of Salt

October 28th 2008 06:37
I always thought the expression "pillar of salt" was based on some abstract concept - randomly plucked out of the universe - for the ultimate punishment, but had no tangible physical reference. The expression features in the bible and people still use it to colourfully describe when a person is damned or morally condemned.

But why salt?

I thought maybe an oxymoron, the torment of the impossible like emptying the ocean with a spoon or going through the eye of a needle. I was visualising table salt being formed into a pillar, you would imagine all the grains blowing away in the wind, perhaps the punishment was to be eternally scattered? Or perhaps salt was short for basalt? Or perhaps salt was supposed to indicate pain, like rubbing salt in a wound?

How wrong i was!

Earlier this year I watched a documentary on the people of the Sahara which showed the merchants of the salt caravans constructing "pillars of salt" with moulds, to ease the transportation of large amounts of salt on the backs of camels.

I recently found some pictures of what modern pillars of salt look like on a site called the Tuareg Salt Caravans of Niger








The pillars are called 'takiss' or kantou' and weigh 21 kilos.

"Salt drove economies, opened trade routes and settlements, even sparked bitter wars."

I wonder how the espressions "salt of the earth" and "a man worth his salt" fit into things?

Seems like in a certain time and place it was a very valuable substance!


photos by Franco Paolinelli







108
Vote
Add To: del.icio.us Digg Furl Spurl.net StumbleUpon Yahoo


   
Subscribe to this blog 


Just this blog This blog and DailyOrble (recommended)

   

   


Comments
21 Comments. [ Add A Comment ]

Comment by Lady Henrietta Muddling

October 28th 2008 07:03
Morgan,

Here's the answer Michael Quinion gives about the etymology of the phrase 'salt of the earth' on his website, World Wide Words:

The expression is Biblical and comes from Matthew, 5:13. From the King James Bible of 1611: “Ye are the salt of the earth: but if the salt have lost his savour, wherewith shall it be salted? it is thenceforth good for nothing, but to be cast out, and to be trodden under foot of men.”

Salt has always been one of the most prized commodities, essential both for life and for preserving food. Roman soldiers were paid an allowance to buy salt, the origin of our salary. A man worth his salt is efficient or capable. To eat salt with someone was to accept his hospitality and a person who did so was bound to look after his host’s interests. The Bible also speaks of a covenant of salt, one of holy and perpetual obligation. Newborn children were anciently rubbed with salt to protect them against evil forces.

To Jesus, therefore, salt of the earth was a great compliment. To understand his comment fully, though, you have to know a bit about where Jews of his time got their salt. Some came from saltpans on the margins of the Dead Sea, but much was obtained from Mount Sodom (Jebel Usdum in Arabic), a ridge of limestone and rock salt at the south-west corner of the Dead Sea (a pillar of salt here is said to have given rise to the legend of Lot’s wife). This rock salt was the literal salt of the earth. Because the deposit’s outer layer was exposed to the elements, it became contaminated and its salt content depleted by weathering, losing its taste and value, so becoming good for nothing.

Comment by Morgan Bell

October 28th 2008 07:21
hi David,
thanks for that fantastic info!
isnt it amazing how people used to be paid in salt!
i think there were times in Australias history where workers were paid in alcohol . . . i think the days of bartering are very interesting!
if Jesus thought salt was a compliment and salt was a valued commodity, do you think there was any underlying symbolism in being turned into a pillar of salt?
like as compared to just being turned into a boulder or some sandstone etc
do you think turning someone to salt is increasing their value or purity?
or maybe salt pillars were just really common and it was an easily recognised reference at the time?

Comment by Cheryl J

October 28th 2008 08:11
Wow, those pillars are amazing!

There is also the expression 'take it with a grain of salt' to mean skepticism and to have reservations. It came from salt being thought to be a cure for poison so to take your food with salt basically meant you thought the food could have been poisoned.

It's amazing to think the world is covered in salt but it was seen as so precious and seems to have a few idioms attached to it.

What a great topic.

Comment by Lady Henrietta Muddling

October 28th 2008 08:22
Morgan,

I'm trying hard not to mention Jesus too much, but since you asked:

There’s a publication titled the Catena Aurea (Golden Chain) compiled by St Thomas Aquinas. He gathers together the teachings of the Fathers & Doctors of the Church on various passages of Sacred Scripture. (There are Female Doctors of the Church btw).

I always refer to them when it comes to these matters.

You ask:

if Jesus thought salt was a compliment and salt was a valued commodity, do you think there was any underlying symbolism in being turned into a pillar of salt?

The Catena Aurea has the following:

St Ambrose says, “Because Lot’s wife looked behind she lost the gift of her [human] nature. Therefore flee from intemperance, by considering that he who turned not back to his old pursuits [Lot] escaped, and reached the [spiritual] mount. Whereas, she who looked back to what was left behind, could not even by the aid of her husband reach the spiritual mount. She remained fixed.

St Augustine says, “Lot’s wife represents those who in times of trouble look back and turn aside from hope of the divine promise. Hence, she was made a pillar of salt as a warning to those not to do likewise.

It's a bit like the question, What do you save from a burning house?

To get this into context. This section of the Catena Aura does not come from a commentary on Lot. it’s a commentary of the story of Lot’s wife from the OT, but as mentioned by Jesus while he is speaking about the end of the World in the NT. Jesus says, “In that day, he who is upon the housetop, and has goods in his home, let him not come down to take it away, and he who is in the field, let him likewise not return back. Remember Lot’s wife.”

St Augustine says, “The person on the housetop represents those who have departed from carnal things and breathe the free air of the spiritual life. The vessels in the house represent the carnal senses, which many use to discover that truth which is only taken in by the intellect, and entirely miss spiritual truths. Let the spiritual beware, lest they again take pleasure in the carnal life which is fed by the bodily senses and descend to take it away in this world’s vessels.

In relation to salt itself, St Bede the Venerable says, “Salt is good. It is a good thing to season the secrets of the heart with the salt of spiritual wisdom. For salt in substance consists of water and air, having a slight mixture of earth, but it also dries up the fluent nature of corrupt bodies to preserve them from decay. Firstly Jesus compares his disciples to salt, inasmuch as they, after the manner of salt, change the corrupt life of men who live on the earth, and by their own virtuous lives delight and season their followers.”

In relation to ‘If the salt loses its savour, wherewith will it be seasoned?’ Bede adds, “If a man who has once been enlightened by the seasoning of truth, falls back into apostasy, by what other teacher shall he be corrected, since the sweetness of wisdom which he tasted, he has cast away, alarmed by troubles or allured by the attractions of the world? Hence it follows ‘It is neither fit for the land, nor yet for the dunghill & etc.’ For salt, when it has ceased to be fit for seasoning food and drying flesh will be good for nothing. It is not even useful to the land it has been cast upon, for it hinders the land from bearing.”

Now, that's enough about my personal friend Jesus. I might go and haunt Damo.

Comment by Morgan Bell

October 28th 2008 08:23
hi Cheryl,
theyre amazing pics hey!
i love finding out the origins of idioms and seemingly abstract expressions, it is so interesting how phrases evolve - language is a strange beast!

Comment by Morgan Bell

October 28th 2008 08:37
hi David,

i dont care if you talk about Jesus, it seems quite relevant to this particular expression

this is interesting:

but it also dries up the fluent nature of corrupt bodies to preserve them from decay

maybe being changed into a pillar of salt is a compassionate punishment, it protects from corruption and decay but it prevents you from moving on and stunts your (spiritual) growth . . . perhaps the equivalent of limbo on earth?

to remain exactly the same forever could be a daunting prospect . . .

Comment by Lady Henrietta Muddling

October 28th 2008 08:55
Morgan,

Now this is interesting:

maybe being changed into a pillar of salt is a compassionate punishment, it protects from corruption and decay but it prevents you from moving on and stunts your (spiritual) growth . . . perhaps the equivalent of limbo on earth?

I've never had a problem with the female take on literature or Scripture. Or reading literature by females. (As long as its sensible like the above comment is. It's food for thought that one).

I've been in the bowels of that dastardly patriarchal society known as the Catholic Church. One of the first books I was forced to read in religious life by those awful women-haters was St Therese of Lisiueux' Story of a Soul.

If only modern women realised how many days monks spent singing the praises of women over the course of the Liturgical Year.

Comment by Morgan Bell

October 28th 2008 09:18
hi David,

im glad you can appreciate sensible writing regardless of gender . . . i guess ones definition of "sensible" will be relative to how sensible they are themselves

i like to consider with commonly accepted beliefs and commonly spoken phrases what would have been going through the mind of the first person who ever verbalised the idea

like the first dude that said "turn you into a pillar of salt", he obviously made a choice in words there, he could have said "pillar of shit", or "pillar of gold", or even "immovable rock" or "bowl of salt" . . . there must have been something quite specific he was trying to convey that hinges on historical attitudes towards salt and pillars

im interested in any interpretation, its all food for thought, and we all have different knowledge and experience that shapes our opinions

Comment by Wilson Pon

October 28th 2008 10:07
Well, Morgan. I also have watched the documentary as well, and I was amazed the ways the local people turning the salt into a pillar...

I was wondering without the existence of salt, what our life would be?

Comment by Morgan Bell

October 28th 2008 11:08
hi Wilson,
i guess without salt we would either die out or adapt to the new conditions . . . i think you can get pretty sick without your essential salts and minerals and electrolytes etc
how bizarre that we both saw the same doco!

Comment by Norm

October 28th 2008 22:10
Is it a bit like worth your weight in gold or that's gold!. Their stocks are on the rise. Money. As good as gold? One day, you can be sure, we'll be worth our weight in adsense. We might say of a person they have got so many ads on them relevant to their site.

Comment by Norm

October 28th 2008 22:38

Comment by RubySoho

October 29th 2008 01:54
Speaking of Adsense, Morgan you have an ad up top advising us to check our blood pressure. Now that's gold! (salt?)

Shame Lot's wife didn't reach the spiritual mount with her hubby really. What wife and mother wouldn't want to be there when her two daughters drug and rape their own father in order to give birth to his kids and start the human race anew? What a way to kick things off. Now that's spiritual!

Comment by Morgan Bell

October 29th 2008 05:21
hi Norm,
beguiling as always . . .


hi Ruby,
HAHA this really is spiritual!
i wonder why more daughters dont go around raping their fathers? ewwww
sound like everyone was licking a bit too much salt back then!
im glad adsense (or ad-non-sense) is on the ball!

Comment by RubySoho

October 29th 2008 12:10
Who knows Morgan? I guess they just did things differently back then. I think it's either a case of the daughters acting out revenge on their father for offering them up to the men of Sodom to be raped and pillaged or maybe just a case of family bonding?

Either way, it was heaven sent and I"m sure Jehovah was really proud. Who wouldn't be? Get your decrepit old father shitfaced and f$%#k his brains out. God I love the Bible. It's where I go when I need a lesson in morality.

Comment by Morgan Bell

October 29th 2008 12:14
hi Ruby,
yeah if you want a good dose of polygamy and incest its the best place to go . . . better than The Bold & The Beautiful or any midday movie!

Comment by Janet Collins

October 29th 2008 13:15
What a great post Morgan. I always thought for some reason or other that because salt was used to preserve food before there was any type of refrigeration it was regarded as precious. Therefore, to be regarded as a "pillar of salt" was one of the highest compliments. But I didn't know any of this other information.

Janet

Comment by Morgan Bell

October 29th 2008 13:19
hi Janet,
thats a good point about preserving food!
it does seem that being transformed into a pillar of salt has complimentary connotations . . . i guess its still second best to being a living breathing human but a darn sight better than burning in hell!
thanks for the comment!

Comment by Anonymous

March 12th 2009 18:42
The Pillars of Salt story is an etiological myth (or Creation Myth, loosely.) Written, presumably, to explain the strange (and REAL) pillars of salt found around the Dead Sea (Caused by who-knows-how-many-years of evaporation of the Sea, and the resultant condensation of salt into big-ass piles)

I always assumed 'worth his salt' meant literally that: worth keeping alive, rather than killing and distilling the salt from his body. I don't know if this is actually possible, but, it was always the assumption i made about the etymology of the phrase. Kinda like in Frank Herbert's Dune, but with salt, instead of water.

Comment by Morgan Bell

March 12th 2009 19:23
hi anonymous,
thanks for the great comment!
i had not even considered the naturally formed salt pillars, and that would make sense as the Dead Sea is famous for its high salt content
i googled a pic of some natural ones

Salt Pillars in The Dead Sea


are there naturally formed ones that actually resemble people?
this is all very interesting!

Comment by Morgan Bell

March 12th 2009 19:33
and with a little extra googling i have found the exact pillar that is supposedly Lot's wife

Pillar of Salt - Lot's Wife - The Dead Sea

Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Notify extra people about this comment
Is this a private comment?
List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this comment


One per line max of 30

List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this private comment thread. Only the people in this list will be able to see or reply to your comment.


One per line max of 30

Your Name
(for the email going out to the above list, it can be different to your Orble Tag)
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
1 Posts
11 Posts
12 Posts
223 Posts dating from September 2006
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0

Morgan Bell's Blogs

6970 Vote(s)
621 Comment(s)
66 Post(s)
4319 Vote(s)
73 Comment(s)
59 Post(s)
9273 Vote(s)
671 Comment(s)
80 Post(s)
Moderated by Morgan Bell
Copyright © 2006 2007 2008 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]